“Yeah, that’s a good idea, but is it completely unassailable logic that is beyond all criticism? Because that’s definitely the best standard to use against the rough draft of an idea.”
The perfect is the enemy of the good. Less infighting among the green left would be very helpful.
I can’t speak for everywhere, but this line is frequently levied at the Greens party here in Australia, but it just doesn’t hold up to scrutiny.
In all of the noteworthy cases where they’ve voted against the “good”, they have negotiated and later ended up voting in favour of the “better”. In no case did they hold up hoping for “perfect”.
But they’re still blamed for voting down climate policy way back in 2009, despite the fact that independent Treasury modelling said the 2009 bill’s climate policy wouldn’t have had any reduction in emissions until 2035. That wasn’t even “good”. So they voted it down and negotiated with the Prime Minister who replaced the megalomaniac that refused to negotiate the first time, and passed world-leading policy in 2010, seeing immediate reduction in emissions.
“Yeah, that’s a good idea, but is it completely unassailable logic that is beyond all criticism? Because that’s definitely the best standard to use against the rough draft of an idea.”
The perfect is the enemy of the good. Less infighting among the green left would be very helpful.
The decades long fight against nuclear that just made sure coal is used for longer… Pain…
I can’t speak for everywhere, but this line is frequently levied at the Greens party here in Australia, but it just doesn’t hold up to scrutiny.
In all of the noteworthy cases where they’ve voted against the “good”, they have negotiated and later ended up voting in favour of the “better”. In no case did they hold up hoping for “perfect”.
But they’re still blamed for voting down climate policy way back in 2009, despite the fact that independent Treasury modelling said the 2009 bill’s climate policy wouldn’t have had any reduction in emissions until 2035. That wasn’t even “good”. So they voted it down and negotiated with the Prime Minister who replaced the megalomaniac that refused to negotiate the first time, and passed world-leading policy in 2010, seeing immediate reduction in emissions.