Vampires Dawn. I haven’t checked out the second and third part yet, but I still think about the first from time to time. I had it in a magazine CD 20 years ago.

To The Moon

and it’s not even close

Omori

I’m not sure it counts as it’s not made in RPG Maker anymore, but To the Moon is amazing

LISA the painful.

Final Profit: A Shop RPG was a really fun one I discovered through a Humble Bundle last year. It’s been getting a pretty steady stream of new content since it released which add to and improve the game

Oneshot

Fear & Hunger

Not my favorite, but might as well list Yume Nikki to make sure it is said.

Hylics

Omori is my favorite RPG Maker and my favorite game

Don’s Adventures, cause it came with RPG Maker 2000 and essentially taught me how to use the program.

Never actually played other people’s games. I had more fun making them.

So far the only one I’ve really played a lot of is Omori. I really enjoyed it!

Started playing The Coffin of Andy and Leyley last night and it is really something that’s for sure…

the first game that i ever downloaded illegally was this rpg series Aveyond and i was absolutely obsessed with it growing up, i replayed some of it a few years back, still fun with an interesting story, i don’t know if i’d love it quite as much if it weren’t my first though

Always Sometimes Monsters gets my vote! It was a good story and I felt like it was a great use of a weekend. Might not be everyone’s cup of tea (text-based, no combat), but I loved it!