While Baldur’s Gate 3 is being widely celebrated by fans and developers alike, some are panicking that this could set new expectations from fans. Good.

  • SkyeStarfall
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    1 year ago

    My point was that capitalism and its incentives do not create good games.

    Capitalism rewards profit at any cost, and nothing more. In the end this allows for cash grabs and terrible working conditions, which the industry is riddled with. Good games would still have gotten made without these incentives.

    There’s many assumptions in this text, and it ignores great games that were financial flops (or couldn’t get made in the first place), and terrible ones (like gacha games or basically the whole mobile games ecosystem) which are greatly rewarded and successful. There are so many resources wasted on objectively not good things for players such as how to exploit their psyche to spend money which compromises the game design, or resources spent on stuff like marketing just because that’s what pays back, instead of spending those on making a better game.

    I would argue that capitalism’s incentives hampers the creation of good games if anything. Because now instead of thinking what makes a game good, devs are instead forced or incentivized to think what makes money. And they are very much not the same thing.

    • ampersandrew@kbin.social
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 year ago

      Someone could make the best game of all time according to one random guy, but if it’s not a game I want, I’m not playing it, and there are games I’d like to be made so that I can play them. Great games that people want to play create profit. Exploitative games also profit, but I’d lay that at the feet of poor regulation. If you want to profit, generally, you’re making a game that as many people as possible will want to play, or a game that enough want to play but that itch hasn’t been scratched by your competitors. How do you make money with Baldur’s Gate 3? You make a really good Baldur’s Gate game, and then people buy it. Even the exploitative games are desirable to their audience for one reason or another before they get to the exploitative parts.