First of all, I’m not a mod, just a curious user. I was told the rules exist because it was a rule of the original reddit and the community demands it. For me personally, it feels like I’m told how to have fun, so I’m very curious if you like/dislike this rule or if you’re indifferent.
I saw the post and comments in question earlier and thought to myself that it was dumb. Having a unique title for posts helps find them again if you’re not in the habit of saving every single thing you come across, so I’ve always kinda hated the “every post needs this exact title” rule on various subreddits.
That said, I’m also not fond of titles that are 100% emojis.