• 2 Posts
  • 171 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: August 2nd, 2023

help-circle












  • Just to be clear—I know it’s said that this is almost a gish gallop statement—but it absolutely is not.

    Since we’re just talking about the headline and not the contents of the article, then this is just a statement. It’s not an argument so it can’t be a gish gallop. If we take the implications of the statement as premises and the headline as a conclusion, then this is just one singular argument which also means it cannot be a gish gallop. Any argument will have a number of premises. Where do you begin? At any of the premises. Demonstrating that the premises are false will show the conclusion to be false. By definition a gish gallop is a great number of arguments that overwhelm an opponent. One argument simply cannot be a gish gallop.