To the several people who reported this post:
This community does not have a ban on AI generated images. Especially ones as silly and harmless as this.
Should a user abuse AI generated images, such as spamming them, then action will be taken against them. But one-off silly images like this are fine.
This take is this community’s equivalent to the sole c/dogs mod (who very recently took over) banning people for putting up facts about pitbulls: pitiful
There are ethical concerns with the use of AI, especially image generation.
c/dogs has a strict no AI policy, and it seems to be appreciated by our users.
This decision should be reconsidered and I would downvote if my instance allowed. Almost every comment is against it here.
I prefer to allow posts with controversial subjects that don’t otherwise violate any rules, such as AI generated images, because it allows for important conversations.
I would rather allow the occasional AI image be posted so that people can discuss why AI images are bad.
I’ll argue that this is a cat community, not an AI discussion community.
There isn’t anything wrong with a comment section discussing a subject related to the post even if that subject isn’t what the community is about.
If someone posted a picture of a cat-shaped pizza then it’d be fine for that post’s commenters to discuss pizza in general.
Good rule.
Scrungus is my favorite, but he is absolutely not a friend. He is a menace.
The people in this thread that ignore valid reasons for disdain towards AI are exhausting. “Just let me lol at thing and move on.” Me, I miss the days of even just drawing a meme up in MS Paint. I don’t want this Uncanny Valley dog shit. It’s not actual intelligence, it exists solely because of theft, and it’s ruining the environment.
AI art bad
AI haters bad
Fuck off with your AI shite
But I enjoyed it
Don’t worry about that. Some people just made AI-hate their whole personality. They take pride in fact that they don’t understand these new tools and can’t use them. That’s a relatively new trend, but it’ll pass.
At least those people have a personality…
Are you implying that people who don’t like AI are akin to Luddites?
I just don’t like AI art.
That idea of that post is really cute, someone could have illustrated that and it could have been lush.
AI art is just an updated version of airbrush art you’d find on the rides at a fairground - it’s tacky.
I just want “real” posts with human thought and intent behind them. Because what’s even the point of a social media of machine-generated content? The more you outsource to the machine, the less real it becomes. AI images look like shit as well, but that may eventually pass.
In this case, the captions are written too well to be designed by the statistics machine. So maybe it deserves less flak than for example that one slop comic a bit ago where the AI gave a glass of water a speech bubble. The hierarchy lines are still clearly hallucinated by the AI and not designed by a human.
can’t use them
Flipping this around so that it’s the AI bros who are doing something novel that others can’t is some galaxy-brained mental gymnastics gaslight move. Fucking anyone can ask the image generator to generate an image.
Lol, because it’s so hard
I hate AI because its stans are so fucking delusional I sometimes wonder if that’s the actual point of it.
Where do you find AI stans? I do find morons crying about AI under every other meme here though. You are the problem.
Are…are we abbreviating standards now? Why wasn’t I told!
“stan” means an obsessive fan, originating from an Eminem song
Thanks, friend
Some people just made AI-hate their whole personality.
It’s being used to replace human workers by the exploitative wealthy, and it’s actively destroying the environment we live in. If you are not against “AI” (that is, generative machine learning models - there’s no intelligence involved) then you are colluding with the robber barons.
That is caused by Capitalism, not AI.
Unless you are training your models at home on your own private server, the current generation of ML models are dependent on the capitalist corporate model. They are trained on large datasets collected by corporate surveillance using server farms owned and operated by corporations, by developers paid by those corporations.
The capitalism and the “AI” are inextricably linked. If you use any of their apps you are patronizing them.
How many human workers lost their jobs because of this meme?
Here is the answer for self-assessment:
spoiler
zero
It normalizes the use of genAI for even more things.
Today it’s just shitposts, where quality isn’t important.
Tomorrow it’ll be one off projects that their creator really wanted to be out, so quality won’t be important.
After tomorrow, it’ll be small group efforts becoming “solo endeavours” with lower quality artwork.
After that, it’ll be corporations within the creative fields that really want to lay off their workforce, even if it means lower quality work, because they can make up with the lower production costs and higher quantity.
And one day, we will wake up to a reality, where everything is AI generated slop, and we won’t be the “idea guys”, who write the prompts for them.
If you ask: not all other technologies were all good either. Cars made us dependent on them, forever restructuring our cities, atomizing our communities. Hell, some of the tools that made creative endeavors, such as home recording and easy to use game engines caused “the bedroom djent kid” and “fetishization of solo indie devs” problems respectively.
That reminds me of Putin’s argument on why a person who threw a plastic drinking glass at a policeman was arrested: “Today they throw plastic drinking glasses, tomorrow they’ll start throwing molotovs, then - killing people.”
The irony in this is that autocrats really love generative AI, especially when it is used to dismantle democracy.
Uh huh, and how many graphic artists lost their jobs because of this model (and others like it) being sold to companies as a way to produce marketing material without paying an artist?
And how many unnecessary pounds of carbon were pumped into the atmosphere because of this meme?
This post is bad and deserves 20 “ai slop” comments because somebody did something else somewhere else using a similar tool? Is that what you think?
You either object to the acceleration of exploitation and environmental destruction and refuse to participate in it, or you are a collaborator.
Luckily there’s hope:
I have no issue with using AI in research and problem solving where it actually exceeds humans. For meme making, OP could have at least made sure it draws an actual hierarchy instead of every node connected to every other node. Or at least fix it in Paint afterwards.
More importantly, let’s stop calling LLMs AI.
Dude. This is a Lemmy community for cats. Your standards might be a little excessive. 🤷♂️
My standards would have accepted a doodle made in Paint. This is lower effort than that, for way more computational power wasted (which, in turn, means more energy and heat wasted).
Concur
This wouldn’t have taken much time or skill to make in GIMP or Krita.
Do it by your self then
no ai slop here pls
Is this AI generated?
Very much
It’s getting kinda good at the text isn’t it. Crazy compared to even half a year ago.
I suspect the images were generated and then the text, chart, and framing were done by hand
The text has an AI vibe to it, I can’t find the words for what tips me off when I see it
It has inconsistent font weight from character to character. It’s easiest to see on the smallest finest characters.
ugh
