Search resumes for six killed aboard plane, the unnamed pilot and a Spanish family with children age 11, five and four
The pilot of a sightseeing helicopter that crashed into New York’s Hudson River on Thursday killing all six people aboard reportedly sent a radio message moments earlier saying he was low on fuel and was heading back to the helipad, its operators said on Friday.
Michael Roth, the chief executive of New York Helicopter Tours, described how the pilot never made it back to the downtown Manhattan heliport it took off from about 16 minutes previously on its sixth flight of the day, the Telegraph reported.
“He called in that he was landing and that he needed fuel, and it should have taken him about three minutes to arrive, but 20 minutes later, he didn’t arrive,” Roth told the UK outlet.
It sounds like the low fuel situation wasn’t directly related to the crash.
Videos posted on social media captured large chunks of the helicopter, including rotor blades spinning independently of the fuselage, falling from the sky and splashing into the river on Thursday afternoon, not long after the tourist flight had taken off from a popular heliport at the tip of Manhattan.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jesus_nut
Jesus nut is a slang term for the main rotor retaining nut[1] or mast nut, which holds the main rotor to the mast of some helicopters. The related slang term Jesus pin refers to the lock pin used to secure the retaining nut. More generally, Jesus nut (or Jesus pin) is used to refer to any component that is a single point of failure and whose breakdown would result in catastrophic consequences, the suggestion being that in such case the only thing left to do would be to pray to Jesus, or that the component’s importance could be likened to the importance of Jesus to Christianity.
In April 2025, 6 people (a family of 5 plus the pilot) were killed in New York when the Bell 206 helicopter they were travelling in suffered a suspected mid-flight detachment of its main rotor blade. Early speculation pinned the blame on an incorrectly installed or serviced Jesus nut.[7]
If it had been just fuel exhaustion, it’d still have been possible to bring the helicopter down via autorotation:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autorotation
The most common use of autorotation in helicopters is to safely land the aircraft in the event of an engine failure or tail-rotor failure. It is a common emergency procedure taught to helicopter pilots as part of their training.
In normal powered helicopter flight, air is drawn into the main rotor system from above and forced downward, but during autorotation, air moves into the rotor system from below as the helicopter descends. Autorotation is permitted mechanically because of both a freewheeling unit, which allows the main rotor to continue turning even if the engine is not running, as well as aerodynamic forces of relative wind maintaining rotor speed. It is the means by which a helicopter can land safely in the event of complete engine failure or other mechanical issue which disconnects the engine from the rotor system. Consequently, all single-engine helicopters must demonstrate this capability to obtain a type certificate.
I don’t think this was a Jesus Nut situation. Blancolirio’s video shows a frame where the transmission is still clearly connected to the main rotor, which says there was a failure in the transmission. If the Jesus Nut failed or there was a mast bump, the transmission would’ve stayed attached to the helicopter (as I understand it).
Autorotation requires either height or airspeed. There’s an envelope where it’s possible, but if you don’t have one of those, it’s not going to work.
Helo flights are stupid common in dense urban areas. Helo crashes make news because wealthy and important people die when they crash.
Speculation is useless because the NTSB will account for every paint scratch and stripped bolt. (assuming that, the NTSB will exist and be competent post DOGE)
One thing keeps surprising me: the number of aircraft crashing into the Hudson river instead of crashing into a crowded New Year City block just nearby. I don’t know if it’s sheer luck but it sure looks like it.
It’s more likely that most flight paths go over the Hudson vs NYC to avoid massive crashes in the city itself.
Especially for the helicopter tours, which aren’t allowed over land in NYC.
Well yeah, but airliners and military choppers have come down into the Hudson also.
What airlines other than the Miracle on the Hudson, which was done on purpose?
Edited to add, why the hell did I get downvoted for asking for some examples? Sorry for trying to learn.
kagis
I don’t see specifically an airliner (i.e. large-body commercial passenger aircraft), but there have been other aircraft:
Deadly NYC helicopter crash adds to tragic list of crashes in Hudson River
Later the same year as the “Miracle on the Hudson”, nine people died when a tourist helicopter and a small private plane collided mid-air and plunged into the Hudson River on August 8, 2009.
Another plane went down in the Hudson River in May 2016.
A World War Two-era plane — a P-47 Thunderbolt — crashed during a celebration for the American Airpower Museum’s 75th anniversary. The pilot, William Gordon, died.
Then in 2019, a charter helicopter crashed in the Hudson River near a heliport after refuelling.
He should have eaten before he left shrugs
It would be great if lemmy could not be Reddit 2.0 with everyone racing to make the most upvoted joke comment in a news story about three dead kids, but here we are.
This isn’t aimed at you in particular, I’m just sick of seeing it because it’s indistinguishable from actual callousness, even if you’re “coping” through humor.
I don’t know what Information you’re seeing, my comment is far from the most upvoted
Time marches on and people can continue upvoting after I left my comment. At the time I commented it had the same number of upvotes as the next highest comment (5) and was at the top when comments were sorted by top. Blahaj doesn’t federate downvotes, so if any were on either comment I didn’t see it.
All of which is sort of beside the point, even if joke comments like that aren’t the top comment it makes for an unpleasant and callous comment section. It’s okay to just have news that’s sad and not make it amateur standup comedy hour.
And it’s okay to bring levity in a dark moment!
Do I need to go dig up some scientific paper about humor as a method to address trauma?
What authorizes you to be the sole decision on what speech is appropriate on a public forum?
If you want to slap a clown nose on your face and honk it in the comment section of a story about 6 people (3 of which were children) dying terribly I’m not going to and haven’t tried to stop you, I just think it’s in bad taste and gives the place a reddit stink when it doesn’t have to. This doesn’t have to be reddit 2.0. We can do better.
Removed by mod
deleted by creator
could have brought a red bull and kept his wings
Hmm. Can helicopters backfire? Maybe bad things can happen when the fuel is nearly gone and the fuel / air mix is erratic. Strange forces in the transmission?
Transmission failure seems likely, but I’m faaaaaar from an expert.
Mast bumping.
I don’t think so. If you watch Blancolirio’s video you can see the transmission is still attached to the main rotor. That shouldn’t happen in a mast bump as I understand it.
