My instance has downvoting enabled, but I’ve learned that some other instances do not. Do the vote totals look different to users on different instances? It seems like some users on instances that don’t allow downvoting are unaware that it’s not the same lemmy-wide. It would be pretty confusing for them to see their vote go down.

  • Wit@kbin.social
    13·
    2 years ago

    I respectfully disagree. Downvotes add a way of gauging the percent of people who support/don’t support a comment. Let’s say I’m asking for advice about which product to buy. With an upvotes-only system the upvote count is biased towards the earliest comment, whereas with an up/down vote system, the ratio helps you detect comments with heavy bias or blatantly wrong facts. So an upvote/downvote system makes it easier to tell the credibility of a comment, basically allowing you to indirectly gauge the opinion of the community rather than the one person who commented.

    • Cevilia (she/they/…)
      4·
      2 years ago

      I see your points, and they do make sense, but I respectfully disagree with your conclusion. My reasoning is that, from my experience, a downvote has no nuance. A reply saying “this is wrong and here’s why” with a hundred upvotes is useful. A downvote is basically the equivalent of flicking a peanut.

      • nottheengineer@feddit.de
        4·
        2 years ago

        The thing is that people usually won’t take the time to write that reply and in case of trolls, they shouldn’t be wasting their time.

        YouTube’s dislikes used to be great for telling useful content apart from useless spam at a glance without even clicking on it. They removed them, so now we have to read the comments before watching a video if we want to avoid wasting time.

        In this day and age, information flows so fast there isn’t always time for nuance. The downvote isn’t perfect and misused often, but it does serve a purpose.

      • yourgodlucifer@kbin.social
        4·
        2 years ago

        does a comment/post really need hundreds of comments saying similar things it also helps to hide spam content and trolls

          • yourgodlucifer@kbin.social
            2·
            2 years ago

            You remove the downvotes you juat get people more people in the comments with “you’re an idiot” or whatever instead of just a downvote.

            It’s not like those kinds of comments are really that nuanced or helpfull either.

            • Cevilia (she/they/…)English
              1·
              2 years ago

              I haven’t noticed that so far.

              Also, even if that were an issue, please forgive me but I’m not entirely convinced that the problem of people posting comments that are lacking in nuance could be solved with a tool that has no nuance.