• merc@sh.itjust.worksEnglish
    27·
    1 month ago

    I assume by “subreddit” you mean Lemmy Community?

    So, you created and moderate !buyselltrade@lemmy.sdf.org , you posted something there. Someone clicked “Create Report”, and as a result you (the moderator of that community) received a report. Naturally, you didn’t ban yourself. But, somehow you were banned from discuss.tchncs.de? Do the admins of that site receive a report if one of their users reports something? Or, was there a separate report that they acted on?

    In a way though, I guess this is working as intended with distributed moderation. If someone had a Hitler fan club community on their own server nobody could make them shut it down, but the existence of that community might be enough to warrant banning them and/or defederating their instance. But, I’d assume there was a separate report requesting that you be banned from their community that went to their moderators.

    What’s funny about this is that the complaint was “Med spam”. Lemmy is a “pull” design, you don’t get community posts sent to you, you have to go out looking for them. So, this is a bit like choosing to go to a steakhouse and then leaving a bad review because they didn’t have good vegan options.

    • copygirlEnglish
      14·
      1 month ago

      Do the admins of that site receive a report if one of their users reports something?

      Reports go to four places:

      • The community moderators.
      • The admins of the instance the community is hosted in. (lemmy.sdf.org)
      • The admins of the instance the reporting user is from. (discuss.tchncs.de)
      • The admins of the instance the reported user is from. (also lemmy.sdf.org in this case)

      So yeah, the admins of discuss.tchncs.de acted in this case. Why? I’m not sure.

      (cc @qrstuv@lemmy.sdf.org)

      • merc@sh.itjust.worksEnglish
        3·
        1 month ago

        So, each report does that automatically? That seems like often it would be overkill, but good in other cases.

        • copygirlEnglish
          6·
          1 month ago

          You’d want all of them. The community moderators receiving the report is obvious. The instance admins get notified because all content that goes through their server is copied and stored on them.

          Also I heard that if mods take care of the report before their admins see it, the report doesn’t go through anymore, to cut down on the amount they have to deal with? Not sure on how that works.

          • merc@sh.itjust.worksEnglish
            3·
            1 month ago

            It seems like there could be a flag for whether instance admins get notified or not. If the complaint is something like “this user didn’t use a spoiler tag for the most recent episode when the community rules say you should”, that would be something that should only involve moderators. OTOH, if it’s “this user is evading a ban so they can post revenge porn”, then maybe you want the instance admins for the relevant community involved. But, IMO, the local admins (local to the user making the report) should probably only be involved if the remote admins (the ones hosting the community) are not doing their job.

  • mariusafa@lemmy.sdf.orgEnglish
    2·
    1 month ago

    You are on the Lemmy mod watch list, good luck! Lemmy mods are blind of power.

    I got one comment banned on an community (in a FOSS one) because I was asking questions of something I shouldn’t…

    Free speech everywhere.