• drolex@sopuli.xyz
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    6 months ago

    You’re really getting out of your way to miss my point. The number of professional writers is some orders of magnitude bigger than the number of billionaires, so much so that taking some arbitrary subset of writers of approximately the same size is easily done.

    Another counter example (because I’m really nice like that): some contemporary French writers, just from memory:

    • Annie Ernaux
    • JMG Le Clezio
    • Amélie Nothomb
    • Michel Houellebecq
    • Erik Orsenna
    • Virginie Despentes
    • Patrick Modiano
    • Christine Angot
    • Jean Echenoz
    • Sylvain Tesson
    • Marie Ndiaye
    • Virginie Grimaldi
    • Marc Levy
    • Alain Finkielkraut
    • Michel Onfray
    • Mélissa da Costa
    • Andrei Making
    • François Cheng
    • JC Rufin

    Yes I know, it’s not 43, but I could easily go to my local bookshop and find 180 more, and again 43 billionaires is a lot for 70 million inhabitants. In any case the number of 500 writers in the article is laughable.

    But that’s not the main point. What gets on my nerves is that the author of the article is cherry picking facts to entertain an idea. I could deliberately try something like “but you know there are more astronauts than true painters” and refute everything opposed to this with No true Scotsman fallacies.

    The article proves absolutely nothing and the author makes a mess of logical thinking, while managing to blur what the wider perspective is supposed to be.

    • mozz@mbin.grits.devOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      6 months ago

      How many of those people are making more than $50k per year at it though?

      It’s not “no true Scotsman” if there’s a defined dollar value that makes someone, so to speak, a Scotsman. I mean for all I know you are right and there are plenty who are supporting themselves doing it- but the point is not that writers don’t exist; it is that the number of them who are making a living without some other means of support is way smaller than it should be.