This would be a great B plot for Lower Decks.
The alternative is that they went to Starfleet and started blasting admirals apart and nobody questioned it after?
Edit: I forget the rank of the dude they blew up at the end but he might’ve been the investigator.
I guess so. I doubt it would be the weirdest thing on the series.
They blasted everyone around too anyway, so there may not have been anybody to explain it to.
He was a commander. So just another typical day for Picard
Oh jeez, this is how we get Disco season 6, isn’t it?
Spoilers! Ah, it’s okay, I don’t really care about it. I did try…
Admit it… you LOOOOOVE whisper-lectures.
Disco is not really a bad show. It’s a bad show, a good show, a kind of decent not-star-trek show, and sometimes all of that in a single season. The whiplash is real.
I will admit there’s a few scenes here and there that were pretty good Trek. Just a shame it’s embedded in the rest. I don’t even mind the overall idea, just the execution is bad. And some of the resolutions of mysteries are…well, stupid. It’s a bit like GoT all over again. I know writers and directors read their fan posts everywhere, so why don’t they go with the best fan theories instead of…whatever shit they come up with?
Been watching through and was really thrown by the end of Season 2, where Tilly just… knows a Queen that’s integral to the plot? Apparently there’s a companion show of short side episodes? (also how the hell is she still a cadet? that whole side plot seems to just have been forgotten except for the occasional remark)
The character was interesting, the show has it’s ups and downs, but that’s only a tad better than Palpatine showing back up in a special™️ Fortnite event.
If you have extended universe stuff, that’s lovely. If you reference it, that’s fine. If you rely on it, that’s troubling. If I only learn about it because I had to google WTF was happening and whether I’d completely missed an episode, that’s bad.
This jives with my current understanding of Disco as Star Trek: Oops All Crunchberries!
What are crunchberries?
Crunchberries are a part of an American sugary cereal, Cap’n Crunch. They are colorful crunchy balls that were originally introduced to add color and differentiation to the uniform yellows base cereal mix, but became so popular upon release that a new cereal was introduced called Oops All Crunchberries that left out the original yellowy cereal all together.
My point is that Discovery’s essence as a show is that it can’t be nailed down to one central concept. Every major arc is the sort of thing one might have built an entire show around, but Disco won’t be bothered to stick to one, so it just says “screw it, let’s do them all!”. It wants to be all over the map - that is the show working by design. It’s an interesting idea, and not one I would begrudge older Trek fans for disliking, but it did confuse the shit out of me along the way before I figured this out.
The quality is really just insanely variable. There are some scenes where I’m like “yeah this is 100% exactly what Star Trek is supposed to be”, and then later in the episode something happens that’s just like “wat”. They’ve done some of the coolest concepts that Trek has had, and they’ve also done some of the stupidest. And the technobabble - sometimes it feels like they talked to a subject matter expert, but only listened to a third of what they said. And the deeply frustrating worldbuilding inconsistencies.
And then there’s the time Burnham thought it would be super cool to just start reading Alice in Wonderland aloud from memory. Definitely some deeply questionable weird acting and directing, but also, there are some truly outstanding moments in places.
All of that said:
I must admit I’ve got a soft spot in my heart for the show for two big reasons:
- they are DEEPLY committed to the core UFoP ideal of radical acceptance, empathy, and diplomacy, especially on a personal level, which is wonderful to see - particularly in the context of how awful the real world can be these days
- guys, seriously, we finally got a sentient fuckin starship. Zora is bae <3
It earns a lot of grace with me for its heart, and I also can’t help but be entranced by the neverending meta-drama of the writers and producers trying to figure out what they want it to be and committing to absolutely nothing for more than a season.
Single season? Sometimes a single episode. It’s great.
This is a great description. The conceptual design of the 10C aliens and the problem solving required to communicate with them was very cool and interesting. But for every one of those you have to tolerate a time bug or the fucking burn being caused by one dude getting really sad.
Agreed. Prime example is Booker, who is best man, worst man, conscientious objector, space terrorist, scoundrel, hero, resourceful, feckless, social pariah, best friend, the right man for the job, the worst man for the job, and all-round good guy, at the same time.
Edit: after typing that I’m starting to think that writers are having fistfights over where to take his character.
Wait, Disco time travels again?
No, well, yes but not as the main thing (becuz Star Trek), but they do find inspiration for the S5 arc in old TNG stuff.
If anyone else who doesn’t watch Discovery is wondering what the inspiration is, it’s The Chase.
Honestly, I appreciate how they revisited this concept. It should have had radically profound ramifications for politics in the TNG Alpha Quadrant, but instead it was treated like a bottle episode. That always stuck in my craw a bit. That said, Disco is more concerned with the technology angle than “oh hey, we’re all from the same place aren’t we” part of it.
Sounds good to me!
