• 6 Posts
  • 2.06K Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: September 12th, 2023

help-circle


  • TheAlbatrosstoRPGMemes @ttrpg.networkA FATAL Mistake
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    18
    ·
    edit-2
    3 days ago

    Tolkien’s “inspiration” for Dwarves pulling from Jews is fascinating, as a Jew. I read that his thoughts were that Dwarves were a strong, resilient people who had been displaced from their homeland but maintained a strong attachment to their traditions and their craft. He saw this as a deferential depiction of Jews and was purposely trying to move away from European depictions of Jews as goblin-like monsters. What’s fascinating is how it is still riddled with antisemitic tropes such as the obsession with gold, their “quarrelsome” nature, and also literally making them a different race of short-statured people who lived underground. It speaks to how deeply ingrained antisemitism was (and to an extent, still is) in the European mind while also lightly espousing Zionist ideas in how living in diaspora is somehow less than living in historical Judea.




  • That one was specially focused on geeky kink stuff and was pretty good. I really enjoyed the rope classes I took and a kind man welded my glasses together after a mishap in a scene in the hotel room we rented to attend. I’ve heard it waned in the past years but I imagine there’s others like it if you’re near any metropolitan area. Nerds love a flimsy pretense for sexually charged situations.




  • Yeah the issue with F.A.T.A.L. isn’t just that it’s text and mechanics are horrifically racist and misogynistic, it’s also a terrible game. It’s clunky and clumsy and it’s difficult to play because it’s poorly written. The author spent more time thinking about his rape fantasies than figuring out how to roll them out in any coherent way.

    Also, very minor in comparison, but the food section is batshit wild. It’s like written by someone who never ate before, the ideas of what makes cuisines in F.A.T.A.L. is hilariously bad.









  • That just isn’t true, I literally agreed with you that it was wrong to teach children in that way 2 replies ago. These faiths aren’t hypothetical, I’m just simply not going to get tied down in speaking about the specifics of specific faiths because that’s unnecessarily complicated as you don’t need to educate someone on every aspect of a religion to pass on the cultural values and aspects of it.

    Though I agree we’re at an impasse here and neither of us are able to communicate something valuable to the other at the moment. I don’t doubt you’re an ethical person, especially with the amount of thought and care you’ve put into this subject, for whatever that’s worth.



  • You’re making a few assumptions that simply aren’t globally true, though. 1) That all religious people follow one of the major world religions you’re describing, 2) that all practitioners of those religions follow every rule to the letter, 3) that all religion is taught to children in a vacuum without other, reality based, education alongside it

    That simply isn’t representative of the entirety of religious practice by a longshot. And in doing so, you’re ignoring the significance of the cultural aspects of faiths.

    Edit: I think the answer would be different if the question was “is it ethical to raise children as orthodox-to-the-letter Catholic Christian” (a few posters have shared some anecdotes that clearly demonstrate the harms with this idea) but it isn’t. The question is if it is ethical to raise children with any religious education whatsoever.