I often see mentions of the disunity in the left and it being a real show stopper for achieving anything meaningful. Whats your take on that and also do you have any reasons(experiences, arguments etc) for that?

  • Rozaŭtuno
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    edit-2
    9 months ago

    Most of the American left is in fact unified - behind the Democratic Party.

    No, quite the opposite. The Democratic Party’s strategy is to appeal to leftist unity only when it’s time for elections, only for them to give no concession whatsoever and keep on their neoliberal agenda.

    And they’re not on the left to begin with, they’re right-wing. Them being leftists is only an illusion caused by the Overton Window.

    Tought Slime - Abolish The Left

    • stabby_cicada@slrpnk.net
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      5
      ·
      9 months ago

      No, quite the opposite. The Democratic Party’s strategy is to appeal to leftist unity only when it’s time for elections, only for them to give no concession whatsoever and keep on their neoliberal agenda.

      There are two different questions going on here:

      Is the Democratic Party leftist? Stipulated, no, they aren’t.

      Does the Democratic Party appeal to leftist unity? Yes. Very aggressively. Mostly by saying “Trump is worse”, and, more practically, “if you work with us within the two party political system you are more likely to enact some of your policy goals than if you work outside it”.

      Which gets to my point: leftists who are willing to compromise their principles and policy goals for the sake of unity typically make that compromise with the large, powerful organization that’s already asking for their support.

      Which means, if you call for “left unity” outside the Democratic Party, you’re speaking to a group of leftists who have already refused to compromise their principles and beliefs in the name of unity. So it’s a hard sell from the beginning.