I have hope, and I will give it a chance, but honestly if the Halo show, Star Wars sequel trilogy (I will never not be salty about that), and seemingly everything nu-trek—whitewashing Khan, changing the look of Klingons, contradicting TOS’s explanation of the Federation’s prison system, and (recently) changing the year of the Bell Riots, among other things—is any indication, it will probably just be writers throwing lore out of the window when it isn’t conducive to what they want to write.
Sadly, with few exceptions, it seems the reality is like this:
Most writers in the past when the lore contradicts the story they want to write: “Let’s throw out our story and write another that respects the preestablished lore!”
Most writers today when the lore contradicts the story they want to write: “How dare it contradict my story! Throw out the preestablished lore!”
That being said, like I said at the top, I have hope, but only because shows like Andor and The Mandalorian gave me hope. And frankly they seem uncommon among the landscape of shows/movies with rich lorebases these days.
I mostly enjoyed it but I never read the books so couldn’t compare. Visually it’s a treat. Apart from some things seeming a bit too “magic” I’d recommend it to sci fi fans.
I have hope, and I will give it a chance, but honestly if the Halo show, Star Wars sequel trilogy (I will never not be salty about that), and seemingly everything nu-trek—whitewashing Khan, changing the look of Klingons, contradicting TOS’s explanation of the Federation’s prison system, and (recently) changing the year of the Bell Riots, among other things—is any indication, it will probably just be writers throwing lore out of the window when it isn’t conducive to what they want to write.
Sadly, with few exceptions, it seems the reality is like this:
Most writers in the past when the lore contradicts the story they want to write: “Let’s throw out our story and write another that respects the preestablished lore!”
Most writers today when the lore contradicts the story they want to write: “How dare it contradict my story! Throw out the preestablished lore!”
That being said, like I said at the top, I have hope, but only because shows like Andor and The Mandalorian gave me hope. And frankly they seem uncommon among the landscape of shows/movies with rich lorebases these days.
Did you like Foundation?
The Asimov series?
Yes, the Apple TV adaptation
I don’t have Apple TV.
Is it good?
I mostly enjoyed it but I never read the books so couldn’t compare. Visually it’s a treat. Apart from some things seeming a bit too “magic” I’d recommend it to sci fi fans.
Yeah, I’ve never gotten around to reading the books either. I’ve gotten as far as The Currents of Space.