Email is a technology, yes. ActivityPub is also a technology. Correct, nobody “owns” either. That’s where the similarity ends though. If SatanCorp comes along and sets up their own instance, they get everything everyone posts. Every message they send. Instances can defederate, yes, which requires SatanCorp to spend another 10 dollars on a host name. I don’t think people understand how trust based and fragile ActivityPub and Lemmy are, or how little privacy there is in any of what you do here, from good actors or bad.
Email by design does not send everyone’s email to everyone else’s server. It’s not a good comparison.
Remember Usenet? Pepperidge Farms remembers.
You’re missing their point.
No, I’m not. It’s a terrible “point”.
Email is a technology, yes. ActivityPub is also a technology. Correct, nobody “owns” either. That’s where the similarity ends though. If SatanCorp comes along and sets up their own instance, they get everything everyone posts. Every message they send. Instances can defederate, yes, which requires SatanCorp to spend another 10 dollars on a host name. I don’t think people understand how trust based and fragile ActivityPub and Lemmy are, or how little privacy there is in any of what you do here, from good actors or bad.
You just can’t gey the point, huh?
Sure. Why don’t you enlighten me?
I’ll give you a hint. Try reading the original thread but put aside your own agenda.
No, I want you to tell me what the point is. Seems like it’s obvious to you?
I rather you learn to fish than me hamd you a fish. You got this!
How embarrassing for us both. Me unable to get the point, and you unable to convey it. A real failure of communication.
https://gui.fediseer.com/ already allows instances to establish trust with each other.
If a scenario like yours happens, admins would probably switch to an allow list model where new instances need to demonstrate trust
They can already scrap all the content.
What you’re suggesting is defederation by default. On the “fediverse”.