Precordial thumps getting dropped from the EMS scope made me sad (paramedic here). They have a lot of utility, especially for us because we’re pretty much on top of the patient the whole ride, so we’re generally going to notice when they code. The problem is that it’s a lack of training. Most people weren’t even asked to practice the technique, you just read about it and got a slap on the ass on the way out the door. I mean, can you imagine teaching CPR or intubation that way? It’d be a fucking disaster. Little wonder people were doing it wrong and causing harm.
Imo, too often the medical field’s answer to “people are doing this wrong” is “fuck it, we’re taking it away”, when it should be “do more (effective) training”.
Precordial thumps getting dropped from the EMS scope made me sad (paramedic here). They have a lot of utility, especially for us because we’re pretty much on top of the patient the whole ride, so we’re generally going to notice when they code. The problem is that it’s a lack of training. Most people weren’t even asked to practice the technique, you just read about it and got a slap on the ass on the way out the door. I mean, can you imagine teaching CPR or intubation that way? It’d be a fucking disaster. Little wonder people were doing it wrong and causing harm.
Imo, too often the medical field’s answer to “people are doing this wrong” is “fuck it, we’re taking it away”, when it should be “do more (effective) training”.