I’m saying that they check a bunch of the boxes of a shill account.
Okay though, sure. My response to the content is contained in the OP meme: Even if we posit that Gaza is 100% Biden’s doing and he’s a lesser evil, which I don’t agree with, but even positing that, this “oh boo hoo I have to swallow my pride and vote for the person who doesn’t want to impose 30% inflation on Iran for no fucking reason and ‘finish the job’ in Gaza and separate Hispanic kids from their families and do mass deportations, I don’t want to, that would mean swallowing my pride, so I won’t and you shouldn’t either” viewpoint is childish, incredibly destructive, and probably not a sincere point of view, but instead a deliberate deception to produce an incredibly destructive result in US politics that may do quite a lot of harm to quite a lot of people.
It’s born – if it is sincere – out of an incredibly selfish and entitled mindset. There are people in the world who don’t have the luxury of deciding to do things they do or don’t want to; there are hungry families in Iran, dead Kurds, dead Ukrainians, Honduran kids who will never see their families again, who absolutely don’t give the slightest shit what you do or don’t feel like voting for, or whether you’re emotionally motivated to take a single trivial action that you can do that might help keep their families alive. They don’t have the luxury of looking at things that way.
That’s as it’s applied to the US. I’m not really familiar enough with UK politics to say the details of how it applies in the UK – but the logic is universally bad. For example if someone was saying not to vote against Boris Johnson for the same absolutely bad-faith and horrifyingly wrong reasons, I would feel free to disagree with them firmly in exactly the same way.
I’m saying that they check a bunch of the boxes of a shill account.
one of our accounts is 8 months old and talks about a variety of other general interests and things that arent just to do with politics as well as modding several of the queer comms in lemmy.blahaj.zone; the other is a three month old account that exclusively posts about politics and martialling people to vote for the democrats and stuff, there’s far more grounds to call you a “shill” for the democrats than to call me a “shill” for the british Green Party or Jeremy Corbyn or whatever.
and one of the points i made was literally that the people now who are saying to vote for Keir Starmer against Rishi Sunak now are literally the same people who voted for Boris Johnson to stop Jeremy Corbyn coming into power because he was “too left wing” just five years ago but now i have to fall in line behind them when they utterly tanked the labour party and refused to fall in line just a few years ago unless we let them be in charge and push their transphobic neoliberal zionist ideology instead, one of the old mainstays of this group, David Mencer, the former director of Labour Friends of Israel, is now literally working for the Israeli government as an official spokesperson
I’m saying that they check a bunch of the boxes of a shill account.
Okay though, sure. My response to the content is contained in the OP meme: Even if we posit that Gaza is 100% Biden’s doing and he’s a lesser evil, which I don’t agree with, but even positing that, this “oh boo hoo I have to swallow my pride and vote for the person who doesn’t want to impose 30% inflation on Iran for no fucking reason and ‘finish the job’ in Gaza and separate Hispanic kids from their families and do mass deportations, I don’t want to, that would mean swallowing my pride, so I won’t and you shouldn’t either” viewpoint is childish, incredibly destructive, and probably not a sincere point of view, but instead a deliberate deception to produce an incredibly destructive result in US politics that may do quite a lot of harm to quite a lot of people.
It’s born – if it is sincere – out of an incredibly selfish and entitled mindset. There are people in the world who don’t have the luxury of deciding to do things they do or don’t want to; there are hungry families in Iran, dead Kurds, dead Ukrainians, Honduran kids who will never see their families again, who absolutely don’t give the slightest shit what you do or don’t feel like voting for, or whether you’re emotionally motivated to take a single trivial action that you can do that might help keep their families alive. They don’t have the luxury of looking at things that way.
That’s as it’s applied to the US. I’m not really familiar enough with UK politics to say the details of how it applies in the UK – but the logic is universally bad. For example if someone was saying not to vote against Boris Johnson for the same absolutely bad-faith and horrifyingly wrong reasons, I would feel free to disagree with them firmly in exactly the same way.
one of our accounts is 8 months old and talks about a variety of other general interests and things that arent just to do with politics as well as modding several of the queer comms in lemmy.blahaj.zone; the other is a three month old account that exclusively posts about politics and martialling people to vote for the democrats and stuff, there’s far more grounds to call you a “shill” for the democrats than to call me a “shill” for the british Green Party or Jeremy Corbyn or whatever.
and one of the points i made was literally that the people now who are saying to vote for Keir Starmer against Rishi Sunak now are literally the same people who voted for Boris Johnson to stop Jeremy Corbyn coming into power because he was “too left wing” just five years ago but now i have to fall in line behind them when they utterly tanked the labour party and refused to fall in line just a few years ago unless we let them be in charge and push their transphobic neoliberal zionist ideology instead, one of the old mainstays of this group, David Mencer, the former director of Labour Friends of Israel, is now literally working for the Israeli government as an official spokesperson
This is another of the talking points / common misleading framings I see a lot
Just wanted to highlight it – I feel pretty comfortable with what I already laid out otherwise