• @dohpaz42@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    49
    edit-2
    26 days ago

    Remember kids, God is all-powerful, all-knowing, and created EVERYTHING; including evil and suffering.

    This means that God created evil, knowing full well what that meant for us humans. He knew Adam was going to eat the apple, and lie to him about it, but still got angry that he was lied to; so angry that he damned the rest of humanity as punishment.

    So if God created evil, and knew what that would do for all of humanity, and it was a part of his great plan to do so, then God must also be evil.

    You can’t have it both ways. He can’t be good and not evil if he created evil. He also lets it happen. He can’t be good and not evil if he knows every mistake we will make, and knowing the impact of our mistakes (i.e., the other people it affects). This makes God culpable for our sins, yet he is not held accountable for his inaction.

    • @ModernEraCaveman@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      1
      edit-2
      11 hours ago

      Think of it quantum mechanically, God is aware of all possible outcomes, of which Adam lying to Him was but one of the many possible consequences of free will (note that the forbidden fruit gave them knowledge of their nakedness, they already had free will). Free will is inherently incompatible with determinism unless we account for all possibilities resulting of free will. Quantum mechanics and superposition theory is the closest we can get to understanding the machinations of God. Even then it still doesn’t help in the least.

    • @RadicalEagle@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      1826 days ago

      In my opinion the only god worth thinking about is one that is beyond human comprehension. Once you restrict a god to only only following human logic god ceases to be interesting.

    • @Pirasp@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      1526 days ago

      Honestly, anyone who says god is all powerful and all knowing clearly hasn’t read the Bible. There is a clear character arc there, and that’s absolutely incompatible with those two assumptions.

      I man, look at the whole Jesus thing! He makes himself human to see why the humans can’t be good, he does retain at least some of his godly powers in human form tho. Even as God made human he has outbursts of rage and is at least at one time incredibly inconsiderate to his parents. Clear character faults if you ask me. At the end he is like “shit was hard man, goddamn!” and changes toe policy for going to heaven completely.

      • @dohpaz42@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        1726 days ago

        Don’t forget how he raped a child to impregnate her, thus also committing adultery and breaking one of his own commandments at the same time, just so he could send his “only begotten son” to die, just to effectively give up and never return.

        • @Pirasp@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          226 days ago

          Not enough info to meaningfully talk about rape imho, and the ‘son’ thing is a bit complicated. Probably more correctly described as a kind of aspect?

          • @KillerTofu@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            1226 days ago

            So like conservatives in ‘Merica he just makes a woman have a child by sheer force of will. No rape involved!

            • @Pirasp@lemmy.world
              link
              fedilink
              226 days ago

              Rape means no consent, has nothing to do with the unconventional way of conception. The entire passage is so imprecisely written, that I don’t think you can for sure say it would have been rape.

              • Bene Gesserit Witch
                link
                fedilink
                1025 days ago

                Well power impacts consent… can you really fully consent to an all powerful being when there’s a chance they might destroy your life for refusing?

                • @Pirasp@lemmy.world
                  link
                  fedilink
                  125 days ago

                  First of all, not all powerful. That is what my first comment was all about. Second, I wouldn’t categorically say no, unlikely, but not impossible. Thirdly, why do so many people feel like debating the finer points of a fictional event with me? You guys are almost as bad as harry potter nerds, except you hate the book you are talking about.

                  • Bene Gesserit Witch
                    link
                    fedilink
                    6
                    edit-2
                    25 days ago

                    uh wow, I thought we were just chatting, not debating. Why are you acting like this? I also never specified my beliefs so it’s weird to jump to all these conclusions.

    • @flamingo_pinyata@sopuli.xyz
      link
      fedilink
      726 days ago

      A very human-centric perspective.
      There’s the option that God is all-powerful, all-knowing, etc, but humans are completely irrelevant to his plan.

      Unsurprisingly no human religion advocates for this perspective.

    • The history of Christian theology can be summed up as: a handful of guys said “hold on, the premises of this whole idea contradict each other”, followed by millenia of coping old dudes writing texts and texts and more texts rationalizing why the dogma they were indoctrinated to believe in has no paradoxes, ackshually.