minus-square@OurToothbrush@lemmy.mllinkfedilink2•4 months agoOkay, so would you agree that they failed at forming a classless, stateless society?
minus-square@OurToothbrush@lemmy.mllinkfedilink2•4 months agoOkay, and why haven’t they succeeded yet?
minus-squareSybillinkfedilink1•4 months agoplainly, I’d say it’s state repression. they struck fear in their hearts in the state struck back.
minus-square@OurToothbrush@lemmy.mllinkfedilink2•4 months agoThat’s incredibly unspecific, repression is one of the main things states do and is a broad category.
minus-squareSybillinkfedilink1•edit-24 months agothey were hunted down and framed for crimes. they were executed. they were exiled.
minus-square@OurToothbrush@lemmy.mllinkfedilink2•4 months agoI feel like they probably shouldn’t have done those things then, if they weren’t able to sustain themselves in the face of that sort of state repression like communists could.
minus-squareSybillinkfedilink1•4 months agoI know you disagree with anarchist tactics. That’s what our whole discussion is about.
minus-square@OurToothbrush@lemmy.mllinkfedilink2•4 months agoDo you not also disagree with those tactics, given how spectacularly they’ve failed to amount to anything material?
Okay, so would you agree that they failed at forming a classless, stateless society?
i’d say they haven’t succeeded yet.
Okay, and why haven’t they succeeded yet?
plainly, I’d say it’s state repression. they struck fear in their hearts in the state struck back.
That’s incredibly unspecific, repression is one of the main things states do and is a broad category.
they were hunted down and framed for crimes. they were executed. they were exiled.
I feel like they probably shouldn’t have done those things then, if they weren’t able to sustain themselves in the face of that sort of state repression like communists could.
I know you disagree with anarchist tactics. That’s what our whole discussion is about.
Do you not also disagree with those tactics, given how spectacularly they’ve failed to amount to anything material?