That’s fucking hilarious.
God damned butthurt ass Pokemon fanboys.
I haven’t bought this game or played it, I’m very skeptical of the company and the future of the game at this point, but I also wasn’t willing to toss them out completely, because it seems the game is well-received.
This is just icing on the cake from when I previously saw that post and felt it wasn’t really… proving much? I was skeptical about his “industry source” that claimed it was impossible to make character models that close to the originals while also being legally distinct.
People need to stop fucking worshiping things. People, games, companies, you name it.
We’re all human, we all suck, we’re all stuck on this shitty rock together, maybe we should stop holding some things up as better than others and just be fucking nice to each other.
Everything is fallible, stop worshiping games and game companies, and especially stop doing dumb, unhelpful, downright absurd shit like this. It just makes these people look like petulant children who can’t get over their favorite game getting showed the fuck up.
People go tribal for the weirdest shit, I can’t even imagine doing anything like that.
My favorite game is Chrono Trigger, if anyone decides to take the art style and game mechanics (and expand on them) from it to make a new game you know what I’m gonna do? I’m gonna play that shit, and will probably love it.
As a fan of Sega’s Jet Set Radio, we got Bomb Rush Cyberfunk by an indie which is so much of a clone that it’s considered an unofficial sequel, and we all love it.
You’re goddamn right we do.
Nice to see someone else who’s favourite game is Chrono Trigger!
Ever play Sea of Stars?
I’ve warned basically everyone to temper their expectations with palword cause I played their previous game which absolutely is just a janky ass asset flip, but palworld is actually slightly more competent and has been a bit enjoyable. Despite the crap with the differences between steam and game pass versions, I mean.
The discourse around the game has been baffling. First of all, anyone bringing up AI… Like… What? I’m not sure what they think current AI models do. And even the criticisms I agree with - some of the designs are straight up just the bottom half of one pokemon with the top half of another - are absolutely demented. I saw a long thread talking about certain pals and what pokemon they were ripping off and a good portion of them were wrong (it was ripping off a totally different pokemon) or not knowing about the base (usually Japanese) thing that both designs were based off of. Some people have just gone absolutely fucking rabid. I don’t understand how they live like this.
nothing more agonizing than listening to people with no knowledge about how 3d models or how games in general work talking about “ai generated games” or ripped models
Right? Dude’s whole premise is “omg he had to SCALE the models to get them to match up! That proves he faked the whole thing!!!1”
Get outta here with this dumb shit.
And “artists should be able to independently corroborate”? The fuck? Ripping assets is not always a straightforward endeavor for someone who is interested in it… why would you expect artists to automatically know how to rip assets for any game at a moment’s notice? (And spend their time and money doing so)
So what are the misconceptions flying around?
This has been the wildest guerilla marketing campaign I’ve seen in the last 5 months.
I understand the Pokemon fanboys who lash out against Game Freak after years and years of dissapointments. I understand the Pokemon fanboys with tempered attitudes who enjoy the new products when they get a little bit better and sigh when they don’t meet expectations. And I understand the Pokemon fanboys who will always continue playing Pokemon games, even when they have SwSh levels of quality, because fuck, it’s Pokemon.
The ones I absolutely do not understand are those who seem to think TPC needs them to go out and just straight out fabricate lies about a game that apparently competes against the franchise they like. If they like a monster-taming franchise, shouldn’t they be glad the genre is getting more popular, even through different avenues? What’s the point in lying for the sake of a corporation that doesn’t care about you?
What’s even worse, is that after taking a look at the new, incipient Palworld communities there’s also a loud minority that turns their apparent enjoyment of the game into disproportionate vitriol to spout against Pokemon. It’s a shame, because both Pokemon and Palworld benefit from having large communities to discuss them with, but I’m absolutely not in the mood to sort between people worth listening to and emotionally dysregulated children.
So the proof that they admitted to fabricating their evidence is… A deleted tweet from a different account?
The proof that it’s fabricated is that it was scaled? I’m a damn hobbyist 3d printing guy and even I know that a) scaling a model doesn’t change its geometry, and b) different softwares have different scaling factors. I can’t tell you how often I download an STL and have to set its scale to like 1000% in Cura in order to print it. I’m not printing a new thing just because I scaled it lmao
I’m not saying they did or didn’t rip meshes from Pokemon, but this article is awful
Byo absolutely deserves to get roasted for trying to call out Palworld “glorifying animal abuse” but not pokemon, or, like, real life farms.
The proof that it’s fabricated is that it was scaled? I’m a damn hobbyist 3d printing guy and even I know that a) scaling a model doesn’t change its geometry
no? Last time I checked I could scale a square to a rectangle :P
deleted by creator
This article is more disinformation than the initial comparisons were.
The author clearly has no 3D experience. OF COURSE they had to fucking scale the models, 3D assets from different games and engines are not going to automatically share the same coordinate space. The point is that a lot of geometry that make up various pals is similar enough to pokemon parts that it has almost definitely been either traced or retopologized from the Pokemon originals. Multiple pals are just kitbashed together from random recreated bits of existing pokemon.
I don’t care about any vague AI accusations. I don’t care or know if what they’ve done is legal, I’m not a lawyer. I haven’t played a pokemon game since Red. But it should be clear that Palworld is at best creatively bankrupt, and they used their similarity to existing IP to gain viral success.
I’m not saying it’s a mechanically bad game. I’m not saying you should feel bad for playing it.
But this stuff is definitely ethically questionable and deserves to be discussed, and that is not helped by some idiots who do not understand 3D modeling weighing in about how “all the similarities were faked”. Because they were not.
The only ethics in question are the delusional pokefans sending death threats over a game also basing monster designs on real world animals.
Yes, the wolf looks like a wolf. Yeah, it does that with the pokemon wolf too. Shocker, I know.
There’s over 1000 pokemon now, and let’s not forget how ‘unique’ a lot of them are.
Voltorb? Ok. No one can ever use a sphere.
Ekans? Ok, no one can ever use a generic snake.
Electrode? Oh shit, they’re stealing from themselves!
deleted by creator
You’ll be sad to know, steamship Mickey is now in the public domain. Why can’t people just continue to give companies that have already made billions their money forever!? Don’t they realize that they are never allowed to base themselves off of the culture they’ve grown surrounded by!? Vague accusations should be enough to take these guys down on the ethics scale.
What a pathetic fucking loser
I can’t stand people who go “the thing I dislike is actually VERY problematic!!” Plagiarism and A.I. art theft are genuine issues that people should take seriously, and nerds like this trying to piggyback on the conversation to push their own agenda does nothing but cheapen the actual causes they’re pretending to care about.
Talk about projecting …
