I’ve been on Lemmy for some time now and it’s time for me to finally understand how Federation works. I have general idea and I have accounts on three federated instances, but I need some details.

Let Alpha, Beta, Gamma and Delta be four federated instances. I have an account on Alpha and create a post in a community on Beta. A persoson from Gamma comments on it and a person from Delta upvotes the post and the comment.

The question: On which instances are the post, the comment and the upvotes stored?

  • Rottcodd@kbin.social
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    45
    ·
    1 year ago

    As already noted, on all of them.

    The easy way to grasp how it works:

    When you, on instance.alpha, view a community on instance.beta, you aren’t actually on community@instance.beta. You’re actually on an entirely separate copy - community@instance.beta@instance.alpha. That’s the community you’re reading and posting to and upvoting/downvoting in. Meanwhile, people on other instances are each on their own locally hosted copies of the same community.

    The lemmy software (or kbin or mastodon or whatever) then periodically syncs up all the local copies of community@instance.beta, so you all end up looking at (more or less) the same content, even though it’s actually a bunch of technically separate communities.

      • Rottcodd@kbin.social
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        53
        ·
        1 year ago

        It’s less efficient than a centralized forum would be, but efficiency isn’t the only or even the highest priority. Decentralization is the explicit point of the fediverse, and to the degree that that requires sacrificing some measure of efficiency, that’s just the way it goes.

        The goal was to build a system that would be robust and relatively seamless while remaining decentralized. That’s more or less what they’ve done. There’s a fair amount of fine tuning and tweaking left to be done, and actively being done, but the basic system is what it is because it best balances all of the goals.

          • kopper [they/them]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            13
            ·
            1 year ago

            As long as 1 person from an instance is subscribed to a community, that person’s instance will fetch everything that happens inside that community (and keep storing it even if they later unsubscribe, unless manually purged by an instance admin)

          • Rottcodd@kbin.social
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            3
            ·
            1 year ago

            Right, which on a side note is most of why I have accounts on a number of different instances and regularly switch between them - because each instance is at least subtly different, since they each have different userbases, and thus somewhat different sets of subscribed and thus federated communities.

            • Nils@feddit.de
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              2
              ·
              1 year ago

              But if you on instance.alpha subscribe to a community on instance.beta that would federate the community to your local instance, right? Is there something I’m missing?

              • Rottcodd@kbin.social
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                2
                ·
                1 year ago

                Right, but of course if you don’t subscribe to it (and nobody else does) then it doesn’t.

                So, for instance, if you go in through an account on a narrowly specialized instance, you’re potentially not going to see a lot of the communities from other instances at all, even on their All, just because nobody’s bothered to subscribe to them. And you’ll likely see highly specialized communities that fit well with that instance that you might not see anywhere else.

                The smaller the instance is, the more likely that is.

                I have accounts on a couple of small instances on which I haven’t even bothered to subscribe to anything, since their All already matches what I want frim the instsnce.

              • hitmyspot@lemmy.world
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                1 year ago

                Yes, if you know about that community. However, by browsing the all feeds of multiple instances, you come across communities you weren’t aware of and can subscribe to on any of the instances you have an account on. Assuming, of course, they all federate.

        • MrSilkworm@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          3
          ·
          1 year ago

          that’s possibly the best explanation of the difference between a corporate social or other media and a decentralised open source one.

      • Falmarri@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        22
        ·
        1 year ago

        It depends what you mean by inefficient. It’s very efficient if you’re optimizing for robustness and control of data.

        • Corgana@startrek.website
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          13
          ·
          1 year ago

          It’s also very efficient if you’re optimizing for having an actual fucking conversation without algorithms or ads.

        • lemmyingly@lemm.ee
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          1 year ago

          Control or redundancy of data?

          If there is a federated delete, I get the impression there is no actual way to ensure that data is deleted?

    • r00ty@kbin.life
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      11
      ·
      1 year ago

      Pretty good answer but there’s no periodic sync. From the moment a community is subscribed to, the instance that is home to the community will send all activities in that community to the subscribed instances as they happen.

      That’s why you don’t see old content all being synced. Just new content (and some old content if it is liked or replied to after subscribed)

      • skankhunt42@lemmy.ca
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        4
        ·
        1 year ago

        Is there a single source of truth? It really sounds like split brain is possible?

        All instances may have their own copy but I imagine the community the instance was posted on is important and need to be up?

        • r00ty@kbin.life
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          6
          ·
          edit-2
          1 year ago

          Well, the answer is “it depends”

          For the community as a whole, I would say that the instance that hosts the community must be up to federate any new posts to other instances. Because it works a bit like:

          Instance A hosts Community 01.
          Instance B user posts to Community 01.
          Instance B federates the post to Instance A
          Instance A federates the post to Instances C, and D.

          So, if instance A is down, the post will exist only on instance B.

          But, federating the posts and comments themselves is not the only way an instance will get posts and comments. Consider the following situation. The post above exists on instances A-D. But after it is posted, Instance E subscribes to the community. Instance E will not have the above post. They will only start getting new federation events.

          However, say for example someone on instance C likes the post? The like event will be sent to Instance E. Instance E will see the like, try to find the post (the post/comment URL is included in the like event) and fail. So, it will then look up the original post. Here’s where it gets interesting. That URL will not be on Instance A where the community lives, but on Instance B where it was posted. So, in this case, if Instance B is down, Instance E will not be able to fetch the post.

          However, if all the instances are up, Instance E will get the post add the like and add to database. This is why when subscribing to instances you will get some old content appear but not all. Because if the old content is interacted with, it will be fetched to render the interactions.

          This understanding is based on my understanding of kbin federation. But, I would be very surprised if lemmy did not work the same.

          EDIT:

          To be clear, to see what already is federated no other instances except the one you’re visiting need to be up. For federation of live events happening to a community, the instance hosting the community must be up and to fetch content needed for a federation event (for which the referenced object was not received via federation), the instance the content was created must be up.