• AllonzeeLV@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    59
    ·
    edit-2
    10 months ago

    It certainly didn’t live up to Federation ideals.

    But then again Sisko should be a war criminal for using Biogenic weapons.

    If you want to see someone do the ethically correct thing 10/10, even in the face of Starfleet failing to, Jean Luc is your captain.

    I’ll bet Janeway and Sisko’s music playlists are a lot more fun though.

    • AuroraBorealis@pawb.social
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      35
      ·
      10 months ago

      The whole theme of the show is the battle of the ideals which work great in the alpha quadrant vs the reality of their situation

        • R0cket_M00se@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          33
          ·
          10 months ago

          Yeah, he was largely operating in safe space and still made some unethical decisions.

          Janeway was willing to make the hard calls that would best serve her ship and it’s future, having your cook and your third in command get fused isn’t exactly going to result in a functioning chain of command.

          Plus since the operation could be reversed, you could argue that Tuvok and Neelix aren’t actually dead, merely suspended animation like storing people in a transporter buffer. You’re still killing Tuvix, but sacrificing one to save two is “the needs of the many” in it’s most simplistic form even without the added weight of hundreds of lives depending on Tuvok’s leadership and tactical skills.

          I never once considered Janeway to be out of line given her circumstances. The crew always comes first even at the cost of her own humanity and ethics. She’s a good captain, willing to make the call that ends lives and live with it so that others may not have to endure those decisions and consequences. She didn’t ask anyone else to do that for her.

          • Zorque@kbin.social
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            12
            ·
            10 months ago

            I mean, DS9 was almost as much in the boonies as Voyager. Assistance was limited, and there were limitations on what he could do, as he was only running the station at the behest of the Bajoran government, not as a true representative of the Federation.

            It also introduced facets of war, even before it became a full blown thing in the later seasons. He wasn’t always on the side of the angels… because there are no angels in war. War only ever makes demons.

            It doesn’t excuse his actions, but it doesn’t make them truly inexcusable either. They both operated in much more of a grey area than either of the two previous series.

            • R0cket_M00se@lemmy.world
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              11
              ·
              10 months ago

              Bajoran space was far away but not impossibly so from Federation resources, I’m not trying to say he’s a bad Captain, merely that the comparison to Janeway is a complete farce. If we are being fair they both fail to uphold the federation’s ideals.

              If we are being reasonable, they both did what they had to do in order to save lives and get the job done.

              My issue is the constant Trekky tendency to pretend Janeway is a shit bag and Sisko is somehow better, it’s just bias.

    • Irv@midwest.social
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      21
      ·
      10 months ago

      There are a lot of instances where the Enterprise crew wanted to do the ethical thing, and Picard stops it or tries to. For example, when Dr. Crusher wanted to help when that planet population was addicted to drugs, and Picard wouldn’t let her do that or communicate anything to them.

      Also, Data once found humans frozen in space, and when he helped them, Picard was annoyed; it wasn’t even a Prime Directive issue!

    • MintyAnt@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      12
      ·
      10 months ago

      The biogenic stuff is so funny for some reason… The absolute absurdity of Sisko bio nuking a planet to get one terrorist

    • It's A Faaaahhkeah!@lemmus.org
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      6
      ·
      10 months ago

      I believe the only reason nothing happened to him was because of Bajor, with him being seen as an Emissary to the Bajoran people, punishing Sisko would Punishing the Prophets chosen one, they wanted Bajor in the federation no matter what, that was the end goal, so leaving Sisko essentially unpunished was right for the greater goal of bringing in Bajor.

  • PM_Your_Nudes_Please@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    52
    ·
    edit-2
    10 months ago

    Tuvix is literally just a Trolley Problem scenario with a fancy costume. No more, no less. And the whole point of the trolley problem is that there isn’t any single “correct” answer.

    There is an out of control trolley. You can’t stop it. On the trolley’s current track, there are two people. If you do nothing, they will die when the trolley hits them. But you’re at a track switch, and can divert the trolley to an alternate track. On that second track, there is one person who will die if the trolley hits them. Do you pull the lever? If you pull the lever, are you murdering the one? If you don’t pull the lever, are you complicit in the deaths of the two?

    In this case, the trolley is the transporter accident; Janeway has the ability to pull the lever and reverse the accident. If she chooses not to, she is essentially refusing to pull the lever, thereby condemning the two people on the first track to die. But if she reverses the accident, she is pulling the lever and killing the one.

    Janeway decided the answer to “should you pull the lever” was “yes”. She pulled the lever, saved the two, and killed the one. Sure, you could argue that pulling the lever is murdering the one. But if you sit by and do nothing, aren’t you willfully (maybe even maliciously) negligent? After all, you have the opportunity to save the lives of two, while minimizing damage to only one person.

    Philosophers will try to change the trolley problem to fit different scenarios. What if it’s a bunch of convicted felons on the first track, and an innocent child on the second track? What if it’s a bunch of your friends and family on the first track, and your worst enemy on the second? What if, what if, what if… But the base question is always the same; Do you choose to do nothing and let many die, or actively kill the one? What is the tipping point where your decision changes?

    • joshthewaster@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      11
      ·
      10 months ago

      Tuvix adds another element though. Tuvok and Neelix were already dead and Tuvix was alive. I think that makes this different from the standard trolley problem - still a hard choice but not the same.

      • Ook the Librarian@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        10 months ago

        I found it strange the claim started with the language “a Trolley Problem” and concluded with the language “the trolley problem”.

        It seems one could make any choice into “a” trolley problem. But Tuvix problem is certainly not “the trolley problem”. This is about emergence of consciousness. In the trolley problem, the characters cease to exist. Neither choice here would end, say, Tuvok’s consciousness.

        • T156@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          10 months ago

          Neither choice here would end, say, Tuvok’s consciousness.

          Arguable, since the result is neither Tuvok nor Neelix, but a new one based on those two. They’re not active, seperate consciousness stuffed into a Tuvixian body.

          And unwinding Tuvix ends Tuvix’s consciousness. Neither Tuvok or Neelix keep Tuvix as part of themselves afterwards, he’d basically die if that was to happen.

          • Ook the Librarian@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            edit-2
            10 months ago

            Are you claiming it is in fact equivalent to the standard “trolley problem”? (I don’t think you are, but if you are, I’ll add)

            If the point is even “arguable”, I claim that is enough to distinguish it from the trolley problem, because that argument doesn’t come up there.

            That was my point. I agree that the consciousness that emerged is distinct from Tuvok (or of course Neelix, but I felt like an ass last time I used the “say Tuvok” construction).

            • T156@lemmy.world
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              edit-2
              10 months ago

              Are you claiming it is in fact equivalent to the standard “trolley problem”? (I don’t think you are, but if you are, I’ll add)

              Not exactly, was more thinking along the lines of both choices involving an end to the consciousness of one or the other. Either Tuvok and Neelix are held in limbo/non-existent from that point onwards, or Tuvix is unwound.

              If the point is even “arguable”, I claim that is enough to distinguish it from the trolley problem, because that argument doesn’t come up there.

              But I am curious, would it not? From my understanding, at the end of the shift, you’re still sacrificing one life to save two, or two to save one, which seems like it would harken back to the fundamentals of the issue. Assuming that no cloning or replicative shenanigans takes place, either Neelix/Tuvok are retained, or Tuvix is.

              That said, there was some leeway in that Janeway had no urgent time-pressure to return them back to their bodies at the time, unlike with something like Transport-split Kirk. She mentions needing her crew back, but that could easily happen at some point in the future, and that might alter the variables of the problem, since part of the trolley problem is that there isn’t any time to take a third option, nor get help from other places.

              • Ook the Librarian@lemmy.world
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                2
                ·
                10 months ago

                Ahhh… I see. When I said “end”, I was thinking permanently, irreparably. Not just pause.

                I like your plan of giving Tuvix a long and fulfilling life while the rest of the crew does fuck all lost in the delta quadrant.

    • Charles Fort would be proud@sh.itjust.works
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      7
      ·
      10 months ago

      the whole point of the trolley problem is that there isn’t any single “correct” answer.

      Yeah, this exactly. However, the nature of fandoms and especially online fan communities means that rather considering the question bilaterally, people will argue for decades and factions will form 🤷

  • Transporter Room 3@startrek.website
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    38
    ·
    10 months ago

    JANEWAY DID NOTHING WRONG

    Sucks to be Tuvix, nobody should be judged on the circumstances of one’s creation.

    But Tuvok and Neelix deserved to live, too.

    If you have the ability to help them, you have the responsibility to help them.

    • SaintWacko@midwest.social
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      18
      ·
      10 months ago

      Exactly! The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few or the one. Tuvok and Neelix are the many, Tuvix was the one. Simple math

  • FordBeeblebrox@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    23
    ·
    10 months ago

    I’m in camp Janeway did nothing wrong, but some things like the doctor in SNW keeping his daughter in the buffer raise questions about just exactly what is being stored and rematerialized. Maybe there was a way to use transporter magic to solve the trolley problem, but the needs of the many and two crew members were already MIA

    • KairuByte@lemmy.dbzer0.com
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      17
      ·
      10 months ago

      It’s been shown multiple times before that there’s no technological reason you can’t put someone in the buffer and take two out. Thomas and William are proof of this.

      The Voyager crew likely had access to the records of the Thomas case, having happened a decade earlier. Though I admit I don’t know if the information would have been classified or withheld for some reason.

      Assuming they had the information, they could have likely attempted a duplication, and unmerge one of the two resulting Tuvix’s.

      I found myself so pissed off this wasn’t even considered during the episode. It’s like they just forgot duplication was a possibility, even if it wasn’t a super sure fire solution.

      • wahming@monyet.cc
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        5
        ·
        10 months ago

        That solution would require transporters to have a consistent set of abilities across series, when somehow the way they work changes even within the same series

    • EmpathicVagrant@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      10 months ago

      We could have saved Tuvix’ pattern, split him into the family members we all meme over, and then used energy to pop him back

  • nocturne@sopuli.xyz
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    18
    ·
    10 months ago

    This was one of those episodes i never really gave another thought until reading about it on the internet.

      • CaptPretentious@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        10 months ago

        I don’t believe it’s ever referenced again and it doesn’t further any plot line that I know of at the top of my head… So really is just a filler episode.

  • Ensign_Seitler@startrek.website
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    12
    ·
    10 months ago

    I think the controversy of Janeway’s choice is largely due to the show’s failure to address the orchid of it all.

    As I see it, Tuvix is not “Tuvok + Neelix,” but also isn’t “something new.” I maintain that Tuvix is primarily the orchid, which has subsumed the essence and personalities of two Voyager crew members and is asserting itself on board the ship.

    All it would have taken is for Janeway to have maintained (or be convinced by another) that this was the case, and it would be the obvious choice to split them back up.

    Of course that would negate the tension of the episode, but it could be left as “not everyone on board agrees that this is who/what Tuvix is, but Janeway believes it so that’s why her decision isn’t immoral.” We could have the same kinds of “was Janeway wrong?” debates, but some of the rough edges would be smoothed out, I think.

  • Blackout@kbin.social
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    10 months ago

    I would have been on Tuvix’s side if they were cuter but I still see their face in my nightmares.

  • SteleTrovilo@beehaw.org
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    edit-2
    10 months ago

    Best solution:

    1: Sedate Tuvix. He must not be conscious for the next steps.

    2: Make a transporter clone of him (like Riker/Boimler)

    3: Separate one of the Tuvixes into Tuvok/Neelix, leave the other as Tuvix

    Everyone wins!

  • survivalmachine@beehaw.org
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    10 months ago

    New Trolley Problem: Would you cold-bloodedly murder a living being to save two of your buddies from certain death? Jameway say absolutely I do.

  • THCDenton@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    10 months ago

    Dude I wish I could be split into two people. I reeally want the Neelix part of me gone.

  • ThenThreeMore@startrek.website
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    10 months ago

    The question to me isn’t whether Janeway murder Tuvix, but was the murder of Tuvix justifiable. In Star Trek 2 Spock famously states “the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few” in TNG Thine Own Self Troy learns that sometimes an officer must order a crew member into a situation where they know that person isn’t coming back.

    Does the situation Voyager was in and the creation of Tuvix represent the same level of danger “to the many” that say an imminent warp core breach does?