I haven’t watched Solo, so I’ll not rate it. Rise of Skywalker was so offensively bad that I almost want to put it in a lower tier than Attack of the Clones, which was just boring. I liked The Last Jedi for the swings it took, even if many missed, while The Force Awakens played it too safe. Rogue One and Revenge of the Sith had good moments, but they also had serious problems. Return of the Jedi wasn’t a home run like the first two. The Phantom Menace has redeeming qualities, but they don’t make up for flaws.
I’m not so generous with this series
S: New Hope, Empire Strikes Back
A: Return of the Jedi
B: Rogue One, Revenge of the Sith
C: Force Awakens, Last Jedi
D: Phantom Menace
F: Rise of Skywalker, Attack of the Clones
I haven’t watched Solo, so I’ll not rate it. Rise of Skywalker was so offensively bad that I almost want to put it in a lower tier than Attack of the Clones, which was just boring. I liked The Last Jedi for the swings it took, even if many missed, while The Force Awakens played it too safe. Rogue One and Revenge of the Sith had good moments, but they also had serious problems. Return of the Jedi wasn’t a home run like the first two. The Phantom Menace has redeeming qualities, but they don’t make up for flaws.
I don’t know you, but I know I respect this tier list.