I recently used linked thinking in Obsidian to do some critical meme analysis for therapy. It was a good exercise in creating index notes, e.g. a meme crossing over Marvel and The Good Place wouldn’t fit in a folder for either one.

  • micseydelOPM
    link
    211 months ago

    Even though I prefer Obsidian now, Roam was like being able to run after only having crawled with Google Docs. It changed how I approach thinking.

    • Callie
      link
      211 months ago

      Can you describe what you like about Obsidian vs Roam? You’re not the first person I’ve heard say they switched.

      • micseydelOPM
        link
        211 months ago

        There are lots of different ways to compare, but with Obsidian I like

        • that I spend zero ongoing cognitive energy on security/privacy/availability concerns
        • first-class aliases
        • speed
        • easy to backup continuously
        • local graph view
        • (while I don’t use it much,) the mobile app is much more solid
        • the leadership and the business
        • I find it easier to do long-form writing

        I do miss Roam’s outliner and backlinks sometimes, but not enough to have bothered with a plugin yet. I also wasn’t sure about Roam’s future, and remained a paid subscriber to support them until I saw how the CEO had decided to moderate the subreddit.

        • Callie
          link
          111 months ago

          I hadn’t been following the CEO’s behavior. The rest sounds excellent, I’d kill for a decent mobile app. My single greatest frustration with roam is the glacial loading speed on mobile since I’m usually using it to hastily type a note while out doing other things. Thank you for the rundown, I’ll definitely be looking into switching over.

          • micseydelOPM
            link
            211 months ago

            I honestly don’t use the mobile app much, but when I tried to use Roam’s app in a doctor visit, it was embarrassing to wait 30 seconds for it to load. It was doubly embarrassing when I compulsively closed the app and had to open it again 🙃

            I hope you post about your experience experimenting with Obsidian :)